Design Example No. 2: Commercial Development - Brown Community Center



This is a sizing example for a commercial site, Brown Community Center. The layout of the Brown Community Center is shown in Figure 1.


In this design example, the NRCS TR-55 method is used as the design methodology.

Step 1. Compute Water Quality Volume WQv

Criteria:

Step 1a. Compute Runoff Coefficient

This runoff coefficient is derived from Schueler's Simple Method.

Rv = 0.05 + (I) (0.009)

Where:

I = Impervious Cover (%)
Rv = 0.05+(63.3)(0.009) = 0.62

Step 1b. Compute WQv

WQv = (P1) (Rv ) (A)

Where:

P1 = 90% Rainfall Event (Inches). Assume 1" in this example
A = 38.0 acres

WQv = (1.0") (Rv ) (A) / 12
= (1.0") (0.62) (3.0ac) (43560ft2/ac) (1ft/12in)
= 6752 ft3

Check Minimum: (0.2) (3.0 ac) (3630) = 2178 ft3 [okay]


Step 2. Compute Recharge Volume (Rev)

Step 2a. Determine Recharge Equation Based on Hydrologic Soil Group (Table 1).

Table 1. Recharge Based on Soil Group
Recharge Requirement
A
(0.38) (Rv) (A) / 12
B
(0.25) (Rv) (A) / 12
C
(0.13) (Rv) (A) / 12
D
(0.06) (Rv) (A) / 12

Step 2b. Compute Recharge Volume

For "B" soils, (0.25 inches) (.62) (3.0 ac) (1/12"/ft) (43,560 ft2/ac) = 1,688 cubic feet; this represents the minimum target volume for recharge purposes.

Step 3. Compute Stream Channel Protection Volume (Cpv):

In this design example, we assume that channel protection is not required at this site due to the small site size, and relatively flat slopes in the watershed.

Step 4. Compute Peak Discharge Control Volume (Qp):

Table 2 presents Input Parameters Per attached TR-55 calculations (see Figures 2 and 3).

Step 2b. Compute Recharge Volume

For "B" soils, (0.25 inches) (.62) (3.0 ac) (1/12"/ft) (43,560 ft2/ac) = 1,688 cubic feet; this represents the minimum target volume for recharge purposes.

Step 3. Compute Stream Channel Protection Volume (Cpv):

In this design example, we assume that channel protection is not required at this site due to the small site size, and relatively flat slopes in the watershed.

Step 4. Compute Peak Discharge Control Volume (Qp):

Table 2 presents Input Parameters Per attached TR-55 calculations (see Figures 2 and 3).

Table 2. Input Parameters for STP Sizing
Condition
RCN
Q 1-year
Q 2-year
Q10-year
Q100-year
cfs
cfs
cfs
cfs
pre-developed
57
0.22
0.58
2.91
6.75
developed
83
5.08
7.11
13.97
22.69

Assume that 10-year quantity peak control is required (Qp10).

Per TR-55, Figure 6-1 (Page 6-2 in TR-55), for a Qin of 13.97 cfs, and an allowable Qout of 2.91 cfs, the Vs necessary for 10-year control is 0.24 ac-ft or 16,890 ft3, under a developed CN of 83.

Step 5. Analyze for Safe Passage of 100 Year Design Storm (Qf):

At final design, prove that discharge conveyance channel is adequate to convey the 100 year event and discharge to receiving waters.

Table 3. Summary of Design Information for Brown Community Center
No.
Category
Volume Required
(cubic feet)
Notes
1
Water Quality (WQv)
6,752
2
Recharge (Rev)
1,688
This volume can be included within the WQv storage
3
Stream Protection (Cpv)
n/a
Not required on this site.
4
Peak Control (Qp)
16.890
10-year control
5
Flood Safe Passage (Qf)
Provide safe passage for the 100-year event in final design